Reviewed by Corey Marino Founder & Finance Broker, FBAA member M-354085 · Diploma-qualified finance broker
Last reviewed 25 October 2026 · Updated 18 October 2026 · About Corey
The short answer
Debt consolidation saves money only when the new loan's interest and fees, plus the cost of closing old debts, compare favourably over the period you will repay it. A lower monthly payment alone does not establish a saving. Compare the total cost and repayment date together.
Debt consolidation can simplify repayments. It saves total dollars only if the new payments and switching costs compare favourably with keeping the existing debts. A smaller monthly payment achieved by extending the term is cash-flow relief, not automatically a saving.
Compare from one date
Obtain current payouts and remaining payment schedules for every debt. Record rates, ongoing fees, early-payout charges and any final payment. For revolving debts, choose a realistic repayment amount and stop adding new purchases while comparing.
Separate the new loan into debt payouts, financed costs and additional cash. Count a fee once: either in the new principal or as an upfront payment. Do not add the old payout to the remaining payments as though both would be paid if you kept the old loans.
Worked remaining-cost comparison
This illustration starts on one comparison date with two existing debts, no further spending and 36 payments remaining on each. Debt A has a $16,000 payout and $530 monthly payment; Debt B has a $10,000 payout and $350 monthly payment. Those payment schedules are assumed inputs, not rates inferred from the payouts.
The new loan repays the $26,000 total payout and finances a $500 switching fee, so principal is $26,500. Its illustrative fixed rate is 8% p.a., calculated monthly, with repayments in arrears, no balloon and no other fees.
| Measure | Keep both debts | New loan, 36 months | New loan, 60 months |
|---|---|---|---|
| Combined monthly payment | $880.00 | $830.41 | $537.32 |
| Payments remaining | 36 | 36 | 60 |
| Total paid from today | $31,680.00 | $29,894.89 | $32,239.47 |
| Total-cost change | Baseline | $1,785.11 less | $559.47 more |
| Debt-free date | 36 months away | 36 months away | 60 months away |
The five-year option cuts the monthly payment most but costs more overall. The three-year option lowers total outgoings under these assumptions. Totals use unrounded repayments and include the financed switching fee through the new payments. This is a worked example, not a customer result or available quote.
Why a simple break-even shortcut can mislead
Dividing switching costs by an estimated monthly saving is only a first screen. Balances reduce, fees occur at different times and one option may still owe money when the other is finished. At your expected exit date, compare payments made, fees paid and the remaining payout under each option.
Moneysmart's consolidation guidance highlights total cost, fees and the risk of turning unsecured debt into secured debt. Record any new asset security as a separate decision, not a free benefit of the lower repayment.
Keep the improvement after settlement
Decide which old limits should be closed or reduced. Confirm every agreed payout, retain closure evidence and check for residual interest. Set a repayment plan that fits normal living costs and review whether extra payments are allowed without fees.
If the budget has an ongoing shortfall, consolidation alone will not fix it. Free support is available through the National Debt Helpline. For a viable consolidation, X Lend can compare the current schedules with suitable new offers and explain the cost, term and security changes before submission.
