Yes. A lower repayment can cost more overall, and the cheapest loan over its full term may not be cheapest if you sell early.
Hypothetical comparison, not lender offers. Each provides $30,000 for the car with monthly repayments. Unless shown, the term is five years with no balloon, upfront fee or ongoing fee. The 24-month figure is repayments made plus the modelled balance immediately after payment 24; it excludes payout charges and daily interest adjustments.
Four hypothetical loans for the same $30,000 car amount| Hypothetical structure | Monthly repayment | Full-term total | Paid plus balance at 24 months, before payout fees |
|---|
| A: 8%, no setup fee | $608.29 | $36,498 | $34,011 |
|---|
| B: 7%, $500 setup fee financed | $603.94 | $36,236 | $34,054 |
|---|
| C: A over seven years | $467.59 | $39,277 | $34,283 |
|---|
| D: A with a $6,000 final balloon | $526.63 | $37,598 | $34,169 |
|---|
The 7% loan saves about $261 over five years, but its financed fee leaves the 24-month figure about $43 higher. A longer term or balloon cuts repayments while leaving more debt outstanding. Check your planned sale date as well as your monthly budget.
An early repayment fee on either loan changes this result; include it from the payout quote.
Estimates use a fixed annual rate divided by 12 and unrounded monthly repayments. Displayed figures are rounded. Ask the lender for a payout quote before acting.
A $1,000 setup fee plus $10 monthly totals $1,600 over five years, before interest on financed fees.